The problem with the gator and most is the item you see in the first pic, a belt. The belt and the clutch either work perfectly or never work at all. I come to the conclusion the most of the staff at powersports dealers are arrogant and can't solve problems so they blame the owner for abusing the machine, for which is was supposedly designed to handle.
Honda has the only SxS with a automotive type auto trans and its darn near fool-proof. All the other ATV's have belts and that is the weak link in IMO.
After seeing the problems a friend has with his 2012 550 and several of my local customers I would not buy a gator.