View Full Version : 825l or 825d...what to do
Hello everyone- I am new to your forum. Just test drove both units and am very impressed. I have a John Deere utility tractor with the Yanmar engine and it is great. I like the 825i but I am scared of the long term reliability of the Chinese engine....parts, longevity. I really need some help here. I drove one with power steering and one without it. To tell you the truth, I can't see a big enough difference in the two. JD is discounting the units without power steering by $700 so buying a unit without PS saves $1400 off the purchase price. Any direction on the glass window vs scratch free plastic would also be appreciated. By the way, you have a great forum here. It has really pushed me to the John Deere. Thanks everyone. Buck
825joe
08-22-2012, 09:24 AM
I wouldn't be worried about the engine of the 825i. There has been a lot of testing and reliability tests on the unit.
DIXIEDOG
08-22-2012, 11:32 AM
I wasn't too concerned with the engine on the 825i....when I bought mine a few weeks back I searched everywhere I could think of to find any negative info about the 825i before I bought one where it was so expensive. I found extremely few complaints and the majority were a squeeky driveshaft problem that supposedly has been addressed and it's not a problem on the 12's and I did see some complaints of people getting the CVT wet in deep water but that's going to be an issue with all of them. The only engine failure I was able to find at all was an engine that sucked some water in...there were bent rods and the engine was pretty much toast. With any of the utvs you need to make sure you don't bury your intake in water or it's going to be a bad day.
Seems like overall most owners are pretty happy with them, the biggest complaint you see that is a design thing is the gas tank being too small....I don't have a problem with mine but I can see it if folks drive a lot of miles with no fuel available.
So far I really like mine, I had a small concern with the regular brakes but it was a wearing in thing....I also don't think the parking brake holds well enough but when I checked my park brake fluid it is in fact low so until I take care of that it's likely to be what's causing the problem...it works it's just a little weaker than I like.
Good luck with your decision, I'm impressed with the warranty that you can purchase for your buggy...not many companies offer you the opportunity to get a 3 yr warranty on an off road toy.:Ysnd:
Thank you Dixie Dog. At my age my gator will not be put through it's paces. Simply a work vehicle around the property and off to go hunting. I guess I am just hung up on the shoddy workmanship I see on Chinese products coming into the States. I do have experience with the Yanmar engine and it has been a non issue. Right now I am just going back and forth and depending on the moment dictates my leaning. Thanks for your quick response. Buck
hornadylnl
08-22-2012, 04:18 PM
I went with the diesel for a few reasons. I have a diesel tractor and generator and had plans to get a diesel transfer tank. If I could find a 40" diesel ztr, my mower would be a diesel too. I hate filling stuff off of gas cans, especially these new cans. 150 gallon of diesel in a tank is a bonfire. 150 gallon of gas in a tank is a massive bomb..
I got mine for 90% work, 10% play. It has plenty of get up and go for me. If you're going to be doing a lot of road driving, the 33mph top speed is a drag but I don't take mine on the road that much. You'll also get at least double the fuel economy with the diesel as well.
thanks for your comments. I am going to wait on this forum a bit to see if anyone wishes they had bought the gas version instead of the diesel. My total road use is about a half mile to get to our hunting property. Of course we do get a bit crazy when the lake freezes solid. Buck
hornadylnl
08-22-2012, 05:50 PM
So far, the biggest complaints I've heard about the gator is the drive shaft bearings and engine heat radiating up through the floor and they've all been with gas models. It could be that there's probably at least 10 gassers for every diesel, I don't know. I've only got 65 hours on mine and haven't spent any considerable time on mine at once other than when it was cold out so I haven't noticed the engine heat issue that much. The other day, I did feel around the floor board when the radiator fan was running to see if I could feel the heat everyone was talking about. Many are saying that you don't need a heater with the cab due to the engine heat coming in from the cab so I thought that would be a bonus. I felt some heat coming in through the small gaps with the fan blowing but not to the point that it'd make me uncomfortable in summer weather.
Another plus to the diesel is if you're going to have young kids or grandkids driving it. It's not going to be amped up like the gasser and cause you to lose control as easily like the gasser would if the kid hits the pedal too fast and too hard.
plateauman57
08-22-2012, 10:40 PM
it sounds like the way you are going to use your gator you couldn't go wrong with gas or diesel. at times i wish i had gone with the diesel vs gas but it's not as big of an issue for me as it is for some.
as far as the windshield if i had known what i know now i would have went with the glass windshield with the wipers. JD is pretty expensive so you might want to check into the Prossum equipment that some have. i hope to sell my top, windshield, and back cage and go that way.
good luck with your choices.
dj
hornadylnl
08-22-2012, 10:49 PM
I'll likely be ordering the prosum windshield, roof, front and rear lights, wiper, and dome light this week. My local Deere dealer quoted me the same prices as prosum so I'll go through the dealer. That way I don't have to worry about being home for the freight delivery.
thank you for your comments. Is there anyone out there that made the decision to go diesel and regrets not going with the gas engine? I talked today to a dealer at the Duchess County fair and his comments were "they gas units have only been out for two years and we have our fingers crossed" I told him that for $14,000 I expected a stronger positive reply then he gave me. So I am still hung up on pulling the trigger on a 825i vs the diesel. Any help someone could give me would really be appreciated. Thanks again. buck
hornadylnl
08-23-2012, 08:56 PM
I don't regret going diesel. I've got 27 acres with 17 being woods. I'm not turning it into a race track and I'm not hauling it all over to go out and play. If I were using it to travel distances regularly, I'd like to have the extra top end speed but I don't. If you think the diesel had enough pep for what you want, I'd go with it.
Destiny creek
08-23-2012, 09:04 PM
The diesel can be chipped if you want more out of it later and it runs all day on a tank of fuel where the gas model burns that in a couple of hours .this diesel as been around forever they are big in marine diesel engines need I say more.also who wantsv to carry gas when one is out for the day
Well I took Sue to the dealer and let her ride in each. As soon as she heard the noise on the diesel she said no way... She is a real worker around the property so I let her cast the final vote. I will be ordering the 825i next week. Thanks for all of your comments. buck
hornadylnl
08-24-2012, 05:14 PM
I don't think my diesel is that loud but I'm half deaf.
cactys
08-24-2012, 06:51 PM
Has anyone actually compared them with an SPL meter? I would sure like to know how they truly compare.
hornadylnl
08-24-2012, 07:35 PM
I test drove the 825 before I bought my 855. They didn't have an 855 when I ordered mine so I couldn't do an immediate side by side comparison on sound levels. But I thought from my initial research, others thought the 825 was louder.
Hi Dixie Dog- I was on the kubota site and see that you went from a uvt 900 to the gator. Could I ask what made you make the switch? I had looked at the Kubota and then went back to the gator. I am waiting for the JD dealer to give me a price on trading in my 04 Rhino. Thanks Buck
DIXIEDOG
09-02-2012, 10:40 AM
Hi Dixie Dog- I was on the kubota site and see that you went from a uvt 900 to the gator. Could I ask what made you make the switch? I had looked at the Kubota and then went back to the gator. I am waiting for the JD dealer to give me a price on trading in my 04 Rhino. Thanks Buck
I switched from a RTV500 to the Gator 825i.....there were 2 big reasons for the switch. 1) Ground clearance....2) Suspension travel.
The Kubota was a lot better machine for work, the hydro tranny was smooth and had awesome engine braking....speaking of brakes both the regular brakes and the parking brake on the Kubota were light years ahead of the 825.
I'm happy with the switch because the 825i works better on the trail and it can still work but for snow plowing I'll be missing the Kubota this winter I'm sure.
cactys
09-03-2012, 09:50 AM
I test drove the 825 before I bought my 855. They didn't have an 855 when I ordered mine so I couldn't do an immediate side by side comparison on sound levels. But I thought from my initial research, others thought the 825 was louder.
Comments about loudness seem to be subjective... and often referencing inside a cab. It would certainly be useful to have a true sound pressure reading of both units from the outside as it passes at about 20-30 mph.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.